Pies
We believe in homemade, mouthwatering pies with real ingredients. Inspired by the original Sugar Momma herself, every pie is made with a dash of love for a bite that “tastes just like Mom’s.”
We offer three styles of pies with different flavors available every week. Find descriptions for every kind of baked, frozen, and fried pie we make. We offer over 50 pie flavors and continue to research new recipes and have fun in the kitchen.
You’ll notice that some of our pies are listed with a wine pairing. Want to be the star of any dinner party? Bring a pie AND a bottle of wine to indulge your senses for an elevated pie experience.
For special orders, call us two or three days in advance at 573-486-5263.
Baked & Frozen Pies
Our traditional family pies come in a variety of flavors. Call for current availability and this season’s featured specialty! Snag a frozen pie for a cool twist on our favorite dessert.
Fried Hand Pies
Your favorite flavors are now available for on-the-go enjoyment! Walk around downtown Hermann or take them back to your room to enjoy flaky, delicious pie in the palm of your hand.
Pies for Special Occasions!
Pies are the perfect addition for any occasion. Birthdays, anniversaries, weddings, new baby, office treats, or just paying it forward. We are hap-pie to deliver for you locally.
Call 573-486-5263 for order and delivery details.
Family & Frozen Pie Flavors
Family Pie Flavors
- Apple Butter Pumpkin with Pecan Streusel
- Apple Crumb
- Apple Double Crust
- Bacon Apple
- Blackberry (Crumb or Double Crust)
- Blackberry Cream
- Blackberry Custard
- Blue Goose (Crumb or Double Crust)
- Blueberry (Crumb or Double Crust)
- Blueberry Cream
- Blueberry Custard
- Bourbon Chocolate Pecan
- Butterscotch Meringue
- Calvin’s 1836 Root Beer Pumpkin
- Caramel Apple Double Crust
- Cheesecake Pecan
- Cherry (Lattice or Crumb)
- Cherry Hearts
- Chocolate Meringue
- Chocolate Pecan
- Coconut Cream
- Custard
- Eggnog Cream
- German Chocolate
- Gooey Butter
- Gooseberry Double Crust
- Key Lime
- Lemon Meringue
- Patriotic
- Peach (Crumb or Double Crust)
- Peach Cream
- Peach Custard
- Peanut Butter Cup
- Pecan
- Pumpkin w/ Whipped Topping
- Pumpkin w/ Pie Crust Leaves
- Raspberry Custard
- Rhubarb Custard
- Rhubarb Double Crust
- Sawdust
- Strawberry
- Strawberry Cloud
- Strawberry Rhubarb
- Sweet Potato with Pecan Streusel
Frozen Pie Flavors
- Choco-Lite
- Chocolate Peanut Butter
- White Chocolate Peppermint
Baked Goods
Apple Butter Pumpkin with Pecan Streusel
We take the classic pumpkin pie and add apple butter to make this light and fluffy filling. We top it with a sweet, toasted pecan streusel. Our apple butter pumpkin with pecan streusel pie will become your new favorite fall pie.
Apple Crumb
A perfect combination of Granny Smith apples, cinnamon, and brown sugar, covered in a delicious crumb topping and baked to perfection.
Apple Double Crust
A perfect combination of Granny Smith apples, cinnamon, and brown sugar, covered in a delicious smooth crust topping and baked to perfection.
Bacon Apple
Let’s just cut to the chase. Bacon makes everything better. Bacon (okay, the grease), Granny Smith apples and juice, and brown sugar all caramelize to make you so happy you might wanna kiss a pig. Not only are bacon crumbles in the apple pie filling, but a bacon lattice adorns the top of the pie. Eat this one warmed.
Blackberry Cream
A delicious blend of plump blackberries with a sour cream mixture and a crunchy topping.
Bourbon Chocolate Pecan
A sweet pecan filling with bourbon mixed in and covered in chocolate chips and candied pecans makes this pie one of the best around
Caramel Apple Double Crust
One of our fall favorites, Granny Smith apples paired with caramel sauce to make the filling, with a double crust, and MORE caramel sauce drizzles off the top.
Cheesecake Pecan
Two American classics, Cheesecake and Pecan Pie, marry into this delightful pie. A caramel layer, topped with a cream cheese layer, topped with a sweet pecan layer.
Cherry Hearts
What a sweetheart of a pie! This cherry pie is perfect for showing someone just how much you love them!
Cherry Lattice
George Washington would be proud of this cherry pie. Try our smooth pie crust lattice top.
Chocolate Meringue
Just the way Grandma made it, cooked over the stove with fresh ingredients, this chocolate pudding filling is topped with meringue and browned to perfection.
Chocolate Peanut Butter
We combine cream cheese, peanut butter and other sweetness, add it to a chocolate cookie crust, and top with Reese’s Pieces.
Chocolate Pecan
Not your typical pecan pie, in fact, it is comparable to cookie dough. Chocolate and pecans create the gooey filling. Serve warm to truly enhance all the flavors.
Choco-Lite
If you love the light texture and taste of a 3 Musketeers candy bar, you will love this pie, in a chocolate cookie crust.
Coconut Cream
We make our own coconut pudding, top it off with meringue and coconut, to make every bite taste like heaven.
Custard
A smooth, silky, simple, sweet pie. One of the best old-fashioned pies.
German Chocolate
With a semi-sweet chocolate filling, and a pecan and coconut layer on top, this pie will make any German pie lover jump with joy
Gooseberry Double Crust
Tiny, tart gooseberries are sweetened with sugar, and sweetened again, and it’s still tart! Pucker up!
Key Lime Pie
Delicious key lime pie with limes and whipped topping on top. We will put our Key Lime Pie up against any Key West Key Lime Pie!
Patriotic Pie
Let freedom ring! This berry pie has blueberries under the stars and cherry pie filling under the striped lattice crust. It’s a new family favorite to pass on for generations. Perfect for any day of the year, or to celebrate your favorite hero.
Peanut Butter Cup
The perfect marriage of chocolate and peanut butter make this creamy, but gooey, perfectly perfect pie! It is garnished with whipped topping and even more chocolate bits.
Pecan
A rich buttery filling with just the perfect amount of pecans.
Pumpkin with Pie Crust Leaves
A classic fall favorite adorned with smooth pie crust leaves.
Pumpkin with Whipped Topping
A classic fall favorite adorned with fluffy whipped topping.
Peach Crumb
We use the perfect peaches and coat them with just the right amount of sugar and just a pinch of cinnamon, with our sweet crumb topping.
Peach Double Crust
We use the perfect peaches and coat them with just the right amount of sugar and just a pinch of cinnamon, under a smooth pie crust top.
Strawberry Cloud
A fluffy cream cheese layer creates the perfect cloud for the strawberry glaze layer, garnished with fresh strawberries and whipped topping.
Strawberry Rhubarb
One of our prettiest pies, this has the combination of sweet strawberries and tangy rhubarb. Oodles of customers who once thought they didn’t like rhubarb, are now in love with our Strawberry Rhubarb Pie. Topped with our smooth lattice pie crust.
Fried Hand Pies
We sometimes offer fried pies. Also called “hand pies,” these small, half-moon shaped pies are deep fried then smothered with a powdered sugar glaze. For a special treat, have your fried pie warm with a side of Ted Drewes Frozen Custard or Giofre Apiaries Honey Ice Cream!
Flavors offered vary by season, but may include:
- Apple
- Bacon Apple
- Blueberry
- Blueberry Cream
- Cherry
- Peach
- Strawberry Cream Cheese
- The Elvis (Peanut Butter & Banana)